Banana Peppers
Banana peppers are a mild, tangy member of the Capsicum annuum family, named for their elongated, curved shape and pale yellow color that can ripen to orange or red. They rank low on the Scoville scale (0 to 500 SHU), making them closer to bell peppers in heat than to jalapenos, with a slight tang that gets sharper once pickled.
Varieties
Sweet banana peppers and hot banana peppers (sometimes called Hungarian wax when more mature and hotter) are related but distinct varieties; hot banana peppers can reach 5,000 to 15,000 SHU, well above the sweet type, so check labeling if heat matters.
Buying tips
Choose peppers that are firm and glossy with taut skin; wrinkled or soft spots signal they're past their prime. Color doesn't indicate ripeness problems, pale yellow-green and orange-red peppers taste similar, with the redder ones slightly sweeter.
Substitutes
Pepperoncini — 1:1
Slightly more bitter and vinegary, especially the jarred version; very close in heat and texture.
Yellow bell pepper (for fresh, unpickled use) — 1:1
No tang and no heat at all, but matches the mild sweetness and color for salads or fajitas.
Sweet cherry peppers, sliced — 3:4
Slightly thicker flesh and a touch sweeter; use a bit less by volume since they're denser.
Jarred pepperoncini brine plus diced bell pepper — 1:1
A workable stand-in for pickled banana pepper rings when none are on hand; dice the bell pepper thin and soak briefly in the brine.
Storage
Fresh banana peppers keep in the crisper drawer, unwashed, in a loosely closed produce bag for up to two weeks. Pickled banana peppers last for months unopened in the pantry and about a month in the fridge once opened, as long as the rings stay submerged in brine.
How to use
Slice fresh into rings for salads, sandwiches, and pizza topping, or stuff whole with cheese and meat mixtures for a baked appetizer. Pickled rings are standard on sub sandwiches, cheesesteaks, and nachos, and the brine itself can flavor dressings and deviled eggs.
What it pairs with
Pairs well with provolone, salami, and Italian-style sandwich fillings, and with grilled sausages, hummus, and briny olives on an appetizer board.
Nutrition
Banana peppers are low in calories and carry a solid amount of vitamin C and vitamin B6 for their size, though pickled versions are considerably higher in sodium than fresh.
FAQ
Are banana peppers the same as pepperoncini?
No, though they're often confused. Banana peppers have smoother skin and a slightly sweeter flavor, while pepperoncini have more wrinkled skin and a sharper, more bitter tang.
Do banana peppers get hotter as they ripen?
Sweet banana peppers stay mild through ripening, but hot banana pepper varieties do build noticeably more heat as they turn from yellow to orange to red.
Can you eat banana pepper seeds?
Yes, they're edible and mostly flavorless, though removing them along with the white pith reduces any residual bitterness or heat.
How do you make pickled banana peppers at home?
Slice fresh peppers into rings and cover with a boiled brine of equal parts vinegar and water, sugar, and salt, then refrigerate for at least 24 hours before eating; they'll keep refrigerated for about a month.
Have banana peppers on hand? Find recipes with our Recipe Generator →