Pickling Spice

Pickling spice is a blend of whole (or coarsely cracked) spices used to flavor vinegar brines for canning and refrigerator pickles. A typical mix includes mustard seed, coriander seed, allspice berries, black peppercorns, bay leaf, dill seed, and often a few red pepper flakes, cinnamon pieces, or cloves. The whole-spice format matters: the pieces steep in the hot brine and get strained or left loose in the jar without turning the liquid cloudy or gritty the way ground spices would.

Varieties

Commercial blends vary more than most spice mixes: some include cinnamon stick pieces and cloves for warmth, others lean heavily on mustard and coriander for a sharper, more savory profile, and some add red pepper flakes for heat. Read the ingredient list if a recipe calls for a specific style, since a cinnamon-heavy blend will taste noticeably different in a plain dill pickle than a mustard-forward one.

Buying tips

Buy from the bulk spice section or a jar labeled specifically 'pickling spice' rather than assembling loose leftover spices, since the ratios in a good commercial blend are already balanced. Check that mustard seeds and bay leaf pieces are visible and not just dust, a sign the blend is fresh and hasn't been sitting too long.

Substitutes

• Homemade pickling spice blend (equal parts mustard seed, coriander seed, allspice berries, black peppercorns, crumbled bay leaf, and dill seed) — 1:1

  The closest match since it recreates the same core flavors. Adjust proportions to taste once you have a base mix on hand.

• Mustard seed, black peppercorns, and bay leaf only — 1:1

  A simplified stand-in that covers the backbone flavor but loses the warmth from allspice and cinnamon. Fine for quick refrigerator pickles, less suited to canned pickles meant to sit for months.

• Mulling spice blend (cinnamon, allspice, cloves, dried citrus peel) — 1:1

  Works only for sweet or fruit pickles like pickled pears or spiced pickled beets. It lacks the mustard seed and dill sharpness a savory cucumber pickle needs.

• Garam masala plus a pinch of mustard seed — 1/2 tsp garam masala plus 1/2 tsp mustard seed per 1 tsp pickling spice

  Shifts the flavor toward a warmer, more Indian-spiced pickle. Good for chutneys and quick pickled onions, not a neutral substitute.

Storage

Store whole pickling spice in an airtight container in a cool, dark cupboard for up to a year. Because the spices are whole rather than ground, they hold their flavor longer than pre-ground spice blends. Homemade batches keep just as well as store-bought jars.

How to use

Add a spoonful or two directly to hot vinegar brine when making cucumber pickles, pickled beets, pickled green beans, or pickled onions. It's also standard in corned beef brine and shrimp boils. Tie the spices in a cheesecloth sachet or a mesh tea ball if you want to pull them out before jarring; otherwise a spoonful can go straight into the jar with the vegetables.

What it pairs with

Pairs naturally with dill, garlic, and white or cider vinegar in classic cucumber pickles, and with brown sugar and cider vinegar in sweeter pickled beets or onions. It's also a standard addition to corned beef and pastrami brines.

Nutrition

Used in small amounts and often strained out or left whole in the jar, pickling spice contributes negligible calories or nutrients to the finished pickle. Any nutritional value comes mostly from the vinegar and vegetables, not the spice blend itself.

FAQ

Have pickling spice on hand? Find recipes with our Recipe Generator →