Pizza Burger
A pizza burger is a beef (or Italian sausage) patty built with pizza flavors instead of standard burger toppings: melted mozzarella, marinara or pizza sauce, and often pepperoni or Italian seasoning mixed right into the meat. It shows up two ways. The drive-in version stacks a seasoned patty on a bun like a normal burger with pizza toppings swapped in. The Midwest home-cooking version, common in Ohio and Iowa church cookbooks, mixes raw ground beef with pizza sauce and seasoning, spreads it on split buns, tops with cheese, and broils it open-face until bubbly.
Varieties
There are two genuinely different dishes under this name. The stacked version is a grilled patty on a bun with pizza toppings added, eaten like a normal burger. The Midwest open-face version mixes raw seasoned ground beef with sauce directly, spreads it thin on split buns, and broils it until the meat is cooked and the cheese browns; it's closer to a broiled meatloaf sandwich than a burger.
Buying tips
Buy ground beef with at least 20% fat (80/20) since pizza toppings add moisture and weight that can make a leaner patty fall apart on the grill. For the sauce, check the label for added sugar; a plain crushed-tomato pizza sauce browns better under a broiler than a sweeter bottled version.
Substitutes
Pizza sauce for marinara — 1:1
Pizza sauce is thicker and often sweeter with more oregano; marinara is looser and more garlicky. Either works, but pizza sauce holds up better under broiler heat without running.
Provolone or low-moisture mozzarella for fresh mozzarella — 1:1 by weight
Fresh mozzarella releases more water and can make the patty soggy under a broiler; low-moisture mozzarella or provolone melts drier and browns better.
Ground Italian sausage for ground beef — 1:1 by weight
Sausage already carries fennel and garlic seasoning, so cut back on any added Italian seasoning by about half.
Turkey pepperoni or crisped prosciutto for regular pepperoni — 1:1
Turkey pepperoni renders less fat and curls less; prosciutto crisps up thin and salty and works well chopped over the cheese.
Storage
Cooked pizza burgers keep in the refrigerator for up to 3 days in a sealed container. Reheat in a 350°F oven or toaster oven for about 8 minutes to re-crisp the bun and re-melt the cheese; microwaving makes the bun soggy. The open-face skillet-style version reheats the same way, uncovered, so the top doesn't steam.
How to use
Serve as a main course with a side of extra marinara for dipping, or make sliders for parties using small patties and dinner rolls. The open-face broiled version is often cut into quarters and served as an appetizer rather than a full sandwich.
What it pairs with
Pairs well with garlic bread, a simple arugula salad with vinaigrette, or crispy fries tossed with parmesan and oregano to keep the Italian theme consistent.
Nutrition
A typical pizza burger runs higher in sodium and saturated fat than a plain cheeseburger because of the added cured pepperoni and extra cheese layer, but it delivers a comparable amount of protein per patty, generally 20-25 grams for a quarter-pound patty.
FAQ
Do you need to pre-cook the meat for the open-face broiled version?
No. The ground beef mixture is spread raw onto the buns and cooks through under the broiler, typically in 10-12 minutes at a rack position about 6 inches from the heat, since the layer is thin.
Why does the patty fall apart when grilling a pizza burger?
Mixing sauce or cheese directly into the raw patty before grilling adds moisture that weakens the binding. Keep sauce and cheese as toppings added after searing rather than mixed into the meat for a stacked-style burger.
Can a pizza burger be made without a broiler?
Yes, a covered skillet or grill lid traps heat well enough to melt the cheese; add the cheese and sauce in the last 2 minutes of cooking and cover to melt without drying out the top.
Have pizza burger on hand? Find recipes with our Recipe Generator →